By STEVE WHITE
JoeBucsFan.com analyst
Former Buccaneers defensive end Steve White (1996-2001) is a devoted student of the game. He’s even authored a coaching guide and coached defensive linemen at the University of South Florida. And after all those years breaking down film with former defensive line coach Rod Marinelli and the other architects and legends of the Bucs’ defense, White shares his knowledge with JoeBucsFan.com readers every week in his must-read Bull Rush column.
I’m confused.
I could swear just a few weeks ago we were being sold a story from the Buccaneers about how important it was that we draft Brian Price in the second round even though we had just used our first round pick on Gerald McCoy who is the exact same type of player.
The story went that having two guys with such high draft grades at the same position to team up with second year player, Roy Miller, a 2009 third round pick, would go a long way towards shoring up the interior of our defense. We were going to go back to how the defense “used to” look we were told.
Isn’t that what we were told?
Well how, exactly, do these quotes on TBO.com fit into that equation?
“We think he’s going to be fine there,” [Todd] Wash said of [Kyle] Moore, who is slated to play first and second down at left end and move inside to tackle on obvious passing downs. “We’re really excited about him.
“He’s a guy who can really give guards some trouble on third down and give us some pass rush from the left end, because he’s got his explosion back. And what we’re seeing from him there is something we haven’t seen here in a while.”
Kyle Moore, as I suspected is being given first dibs at starting at left end, and that’s great. And really, before I go any further, I want to make sure everyone understands that this isn’t a knock against Moore.
But why with McCoy, Price, and Miller on the roster would we need Kyle Moore to move inside on third downs/obvious passing downs???
Let me be clear, that is NOT how we did things back in what most people consider the “glory years” of the Buccaneer defense.
When Brad Culpepper was our starting nosetackle, Culpepper stayed in and rushed on third downs.
When Booger McFarland was our starting nosetackle, Booger McFarland stayed in and rushed on third downs.
Really, that’s one of the upsides of having smaller, quicker nosetackles rather than the big burly two-down run-stoppers, and that is you have a guy who can play all three downs rather than having to waste both a roster spot and a spot on the active list on game day using two guys for one position.
Setting McCoy Up To Be Double-Teamed
And it’s not only that it’s an enormous waste of money to have three guys taken in the top three rounds of the last two drafts at a position and only use one on passing downs. From a practical on the field perspective, it’s a horrible move as well.
Here’s what you need to understand: on any given passing play an interior defensive lineman is going to get double-teamed. The center will either slide to one side or the other, or he will do what we call “M” set and backpedal straight backwards and then, after watching both directions, he will pick one guard to go and help out. But the wonderful thing about film study is that you can usually predict before the snap which way the center will slide or help out based on the formation.
Because of this, you can move your more dominant inside pass rusher to the side away from the center double team most of the time, knowing that the other guy will be double teamed but still have the option to run pass rush games or use bull rush techniques to overcome that.
So being that McCoy as the No. 3 pick in the draft is absolutely going to be in on all passing downs, who between he and Moore would get the single block and who would have to take on the double team?
If we want McCoy to be the second coming of Warren Sapp, that’s going to be awful hard to do rushing against a double team every passing down. If we are expecting to get something out of Moore inside on passing downs that’s going to be awfully hard to do if he is facing double tWeams every time. Especially after he lost weight to be a more effective defensive end.
And speaking of Moore, explain to me how this doesn’t hurt his development as a left end if he is constantly having to move inside to rush on passing downs?
I have made it known that I am not a fan at all of moving starting defensive ends around on third downs anyway. And I hate to say it, but I would venture to guess that if the Bucs indeed go forward with this plan that Moore will end up a lot like Gaines Adams, may he rest in peace, in that because he never gets to rush the guy on third down that he just got done setting up on first and second down; he will never put up the numbers that he should.
I mean seriously, think about the elite 4-3 defensive lines in the NFL right now. How many of them move their starting defensive ends inside on third down?
I can’t think of any.
Even the Vikings, who have a big beast inside at nosetackle in Pat Williams, keep pretty much their whole defensive line intact on third downs and passing downs. And if they do sub for Pat Williams, it’s to bring in another, lighter, defensive tackle in the game. It’s not to move a defensive end inside to replace him.
I don’t know whose bright idea this is, but I am just as against it as I was when they kept moving Gaines to the left side on passing downs, and when they proposed using Quincy Black as a defensive end on third downs, and when they kept moving Jimmy Wilkerson inside on third downs during the season.
It’s something I think a video gamer might do, but it’s not a serious professional NFL defensive line strategy. And whether anybody else buys it or not, I will guarantee you that I’m going to be vocal about my opposition going forward.
It’s an answer in search of a problem and it makes a helluva lot more sense to just give Price and Miller a chance to rush on third down.
It is what it is.