Joe knows Barrett Ruud is a lightning rod for Bucs fans.
There are some voices — Ian Beckles and Justin Pawlowski of WDAE-AM 620 — who are convinced Ruud is softer than the bosom of Rachel Watson.
Beckles constantly rails that Ruud is scared of contract — a grievous and unforgivable mortal sin for a middle linebacker in the NFL.
Pawlowski is known to grumble over Ruud’s perceived inability to shed blockers.
Then there are those, such as former Bucs defensive end Steve White, who believe Ruud is doing nearly everything he is asked in Bucs coach Raheem Morris’ defense. That Ruud is not meant to be a second-level stopgap because that is the responsibility of the defensive tackles, among others.
White, and other Ruud defenders, point to his many tackles. Beckles and Pawlowski point to how those tackles are made on the third level.
There seems no middle ground with Bucs fans with Ruud. Either he is doing his job splendidly, or he is an insult to middle linebackers of the past who strapped on shoulder pads in the NFL.
One thing is certain for NFC South blogger Pat Yasinskas. He of the employ of the Soviet mouse outfit in Bristol appeared on The Fabulous Sports Babe Show, heard locally on WHBO-AM 1040, and flatly stated that Ruud has played in his final game for the Bucs.
Joe is paraphrasing here as he was behind the wheel and unable to take notes without wrecking his prized Ford Ranger, but blogger Yasinskas stated that the Bucs do not place a high monetary value on a middle linebacker in their defense scheme, so Ruud getting a hefty salary from the Bucs is out of the question. Therefore, the Bucs will not meet Ruud’s contract demands.
As a result, Ruud, blogger Yasinskas explained, will be able to go to a team that does value middle linebackers and where he will be able to dominate opposing offenses and be paid an honest salary commensurate with veteran middle linebackers.
Joe has tried to keep an open mind about Ruud. He believes Ruud’s detractors do have valid questions. However, Joe does not know the intimate responsibilities of a middle linebacker in a Tampa-2 defense. Simply put, when White breaks down how to play the Tampa-2, Joe takes notice.
Joe will say, and has, that when an old man of a cornerback and a rookie seventh round draft pick of a safety make as many or more splash plays against the run inside the box as your middle linebacker, well, Joe believes it’s fair to question Ruud.
Now yes, Ruud does rack up a lot of tackles. Those of the proverbial seven yards downfield as Pawlowski often points out. Ruud’s defenders state a tackle is a tackle but normally, if a safety leads a team in tackles, as Ruud has in the past — he was second in Bucs tackles this season — a third-level player, one would ask what the problem is, that a safety should not be leading a team in tackles.
If Ruud’s tackles are, as many believe, all seven yards downfield, is that not not the third level?
Perhaps Ruud is more safety than middle linebacker and just the fact he wears the cloak of middle linebacker is the problem because people — right or wrong — have a perception of a middle linebacker that Ruud simply will never match? Maybe Ruud is a safety in a middle linebacker’s clothing?
If that is the case, would it be fair to say the Bucs defense plays a 42 front and not a 43 front?