Lavonte David Has A Hardware Problem
March 25th, 2026
Click through to BillCurrieFord.com to see their extraordinary March offers. Family-owned in Tampa since 1960! Bill Currie Ford general manager Sean Sullivan is ready to help you PERSONALLY and give you the famous Ira Kaufman discount. Don’t Worry, Drive Currie!
BY IRA KAUFMAN
The Canton clock is ticking for Lavonte David.
Although David won’t be eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame until the Class of 2031, the debate has already begun about his gold jacket credentials. Buc fans naturally feel he’s a slam-dunk candidate — and that’s understandable considering what David has meant to the franchise during his splendid 14-year career.
But as Tampa Bay’s lone Hall of Fame representative since 2005, I’m here to tell you the road to Canton may not necessarily be a smooth one.
I can hear Buc Nation collectively question my sanity.
You’re not alone.
While it’s true David has a compelling case for pro football’s shrine to excellence, he lacks one critical component in a glittering resume. Numbers? Sure. Hardware? He’s a little light.
David ends his career among the all-time leaders in tackles and tackles for loss. He made a major impact across the board and certainly embodies the Hall of Fame’s core values: commitment, integrity, courage, respect and excellence.
Luke Kuechly, who just earned a Canton bust in his second year of eligibility, can’t say enough about No. 54.
“The guy that I feel never gets enough credit is Lavonte,” Kuechly says. “I love Lavonte. Go look at his sacks, his forced fumbles and his fumble recoveries … it’s unbelievable.”
So what’s the problem?
David’s lack of Pro Bowls shouldn’t be a major issue. Hall of Fame voters don’t pay much attention to an honor that has been watered down significantly over the years. Instead, it’s his single first-team All-Pro designation that could slow David’s roll into Canton.
Many Hall of Fame selectors are the same voters who fill out All-Pro ballots. Unlike Buc fans, they didn’t see David play on a weekly basis. They didn’t see his consistent excellence as a sideline-to-sideline linebacker.
“I let my play do the talking,” David said at Tuesday’s retirement announcement.
Hopefully, that will be enough.
David ranks fourth in career tackles, behind Ray Lewis, London Fletcher and Derrick Brooks and just ahead of Bobby Wagner. Fletcher, who holds the record for most consecutive starts at linebacker, has been waiting since 2019 to be named one of the Hall’s 15 finalists for induction.
David was a better player than Fletcher, but Hall voters may not agree he was MARKEDLY better.
Let’s look at the off-ball linebackers who made the Hall of Fame while playing in this century.
1st Team All-Pro All-Decade D.P.O.Y.
Derrick Brooks 5 Yes Yes
Luke Kuechly 5 Yes Yes
Ray Lewis 7 Yes Twice
Junior Seau 6 Yes No
Zach Thomas 5 Yes No
Brian Urlacher 4 Yes Yes
Patrick Willis 5 Yes No
That’s called hardware.
Wagner has six first-team All-Pro honors and was an All-Decade choice. He was in the same 2012 draft class as David and Demario Davis, quite a linebacker trifecta. But while David’s Buccaneers were in the midst of a 12-year playoff drought, Wagner’s Seahawks made the postseason seven times between 2012-19.
That brought considerably more national exposure to Wagner, who has played for four teams and is currently a free agent.
Even Kuechly had to wait a year for his enshrinement — and it’s hard to imagine voters holding David in higher regard than his Carolina counterpart.
Nobody knows the Hall of Fame finalist class for 2031. We could assume David will make the final 15 in his first year of eligibility, but try telling that to London Fletcher, who has never heard his case discussed among the voting bloc.
Those of us who witnessed David’s elite play would consider it a travesty if Canton makes him sit and take a number, yet it happens. Cris Carter waited six years. John Lynch waited eight. Lynn Swann waited 14.
While Lavonte David is no slam-dunk, he’s a heck of a candidate. He may not have the hardware, but David’s an exceptionally hard guy to dismiss.
March 25th, 2026 at 8:41 am
Fortunately he has you to get the job done
March 25th, 2026 at 8:44 am
Ira…. Don’t go anywhere. You gotta stick around to get LVD in!
March 25th, 2026 at 8:55 am
It’s a shame that hall of fame all pros and pro bowls aren’t decided by players ability to be consistent and dominant for so long but based on the more popular teams that played. Keuchly, fletcher, and David should be sure fire hof. I will lose faith in the entire process if Wagner gets in before David with such similar numbers in so many categories
March 25th, 2026 at 9:08 am
You know, maybe he’s not HOF. That’s not the end of the world.
He was a great player HERE. So was Paul Gruber. Alstott. Rice. Wilder. I’m probably forgetting a few.
Everyone can’t get in.
March 25th, 2026 at 9:17 am
It is not easy to get in the HOF. Research the NFL HOF selection procedures. A Player needs 80% of votes to get in. Each HOF voter selects 5 players. The voters have their own biases. Then there is the politicking. If you vote for the player from my team I will vote for the player on your team.
March 25th, 2026 at 9:31 am
See Mike knows what he is doing. He left to try to get more hardware.
It’s a shame but sticking with Todd was Lavontes choice. SMH
March 25th, 2026 at 10:49 am
“Even Kuechly had to wait a year for his enshrinement — and it’s hard to imagine voters holding David in higher regard than his Carolina counterpart.”
Why the hell NOT!?
David only needs to get 80% of the votes from the HOF and has a MUCH better overall resume than Kuechly.
March 25th, 2026 at 11:18 am
He’ll get it, but it will definitely take time.
March 25th, 2026 at 11:31 am
2031 is a long way off.
Who outside of Tampa fans will remember Lavonte David at that point.
I would put my money on not even getting nominated.
March 25th, 2026 at 12:04 pm
Glad you mentioned that Pro Bowls don’t hold much weight anymore.
David will certainly have to wait. I fear a long time of Fletcher doesn’t sniff it in the next 5 years.
I just don’t understand how media attention can affect a HoF case as much as it does. Effect All-Pros in the season where a guy has gotten attention… sure, that makes sense.
Are voters that thick? They can’t look back and factor in the context of David being on bad teams and not getting the spotlight? Then look at his numbers against the guys that did get a spotlight on better teams ala Kuechly and Wagner?
Pro Bowl and HoF voting (after the Belichick snub) are becoming like the Oscars. Irrelevant, popularity contests where you better shake the right hands and kiss the right rings or a bunch of egos will turn you away.
March 25th, 2026 at 12:26 pm
But not a heart problem. He’ll get in
March 25th, 2026 at 1:01 pm
Mike Alstott is not in the HoF
Watch the trend of people watching responding to Alstott’s highlight reel.
Alstott is still relevant today and can’t get a sniff.
What make you think Lavonte has a chance?
March 25th, 2026 at 2:16 pm
Focus on TFLs no off the ball LB is even close to him and that is crazy
March 25th, 2026 at 3:58 pm
He did it playing in 2 different systems. 4-3 and 3-4. Has to get some credit for that I reckon.
March 25th, 2026 at 4:01 pm
Googly belongs in the hall of pretty good, not the Hall of Fame. He’s simply not of the same caliber as LVD and Wagner.
March 25th, 2026 at 5:39 pm
@ BucsMinisterFuller – Ummmm, just a little common frickin sense and knowing how the HOF works. Lavonte’s career has been better and longer. Plus, HIS numbers stack up against all of THE TOP LB’s at his position, who are already actually ‘IN’ The HOF. Alstott’s Doesn’t. His numbers are nowhere even NEAR the top RB’s who are currently in The Hall. But, but, but, YOU wanna talk about “FULLBACKS” THO, LoL. FB’s don’t make the HOF for good reason… It’s no longer even a relevant position in today’s game. And, they rarely put up any ‘tangible’ numbers (definitely NOT “HOF-numbers”). There aren’t hardly any true FB’s in the HOF to begin with. Hell, I can only remember JUST ONE getting in throughout my entire ‘lifetime’ (49-years). Larry Csonska maybe!? I don’t consider Franco Harris or John Riggins as being true “fullbacks,” either… They did it ALL. If I was going to vote on a true fullback, I would put Lorenzo Neal in there, along with Mike Alstott. But, NO WAY they deserve to be in there before LAVONTE FREAKING DAVID. And, it ain’t even close.
March 26th, 2026 at 5:55 am
Luke Kuechly? Luke Kuechly? He was a so-so LB. His career numbers look like 5 of Lavonte’s seasons. If that guy is in the HOF, and David doesn’t get it on the first try, then the HOF is a joke.