Make The Call

September 1st, 2023

Flash poll posted at 8:55 a.m. Poll closed 11:25 a.m.

22 Responses to “Make The Call”

  1. SufferingSince76 Says:

    No answer because both of them are very valuable. I wouldn’t want to be without either. I don’t care how old Mike is. Over a grand every year. He could be the Tom Brady of receivers. Make it happen, Jason.

  2. DoooshLaRue Says:

    I prefer the WR who doesn’t throw tantrum and regularly gets YAC.
    Oh, and he’s younger.

    Yeah,I like that guy better.

  3. Jack Sparrow Says:

    Both of these WR’s are made of glass.

  4. rrsrq Says:

    People are paying to see ME13, nothing against CG14, but nobody is paying to see him. I’m not taking anything away from Godwin’s skillset, he is a #1 receiver, but ME is like David Ruffin and the rest are the Temptations

  5. Daniel Says:

    Literally shocked Mike Evans is winning.

  6. Uhhmmm Says:

    Daniel Says:
    Literally shocked Mike Evans is winning.

    LMAO What!?! You must walk through life consistently shocked then, huh??

  7. Uhhmmm Says:

    Are Jack Sparrow and Daniel the same person? They both are seriously misinformed…..

  8. D-Rok Says:

    Present: Evans more valuable.
    Future: Godwin more valuable.

    That’s a difficult question to answer as written. Both have great value in different ways, but in 2-3 years, Evans really should be slowing down, whereas Godwin should still be in his prime.

  9. Erik Hesson - Fine Artist and Founder of Says:

    For the next 5 years, Mike is our best and most valuable receiver.

    Godwin will never overtake Evans as WR1, because Evans is a notch above.

  10. Divis Says:

    Keep Mike. Johnny Wilson to the Bucs.

  11. StickinUp4Centers Says:

    Chris Godwin is very good, but I have a feeling that he has benefited a lot from Mike Evans being on the field. Mike Evans physical skillset means that he has to be accounted for on the field. I have no stats on this, but I would guess that ME draws more double teams the CG when both are on the field.

  12. Since76 Says:

    Don’t try to compare them. They are both great but completely different. I hate to see Mike leave but I really don’t see him cashing in big here. But maybe he will.

  13. Erik Hesson - Fine Artist and Founder of Says:


    Jensen’s contract restructure was hopefully for a new Evans deal.

    If we announce D White deal before an Evan’s deal, I will highly upset with that moronic decision.

    Sign Evans! No excuses!

  14. Buc1987 Says:

    63 no answers..

    How do you not have an opinion of Mike or Chris?

    63 is high….strange fan base!

  15. Mord Says:

    This is insanity (the results of this poll). Crazy. Wrong.

  16. Miller5252 Says:

    The same group that thinks Godwin is more valuable then Evans is the same that said NASCAR drivers are athletes. Blows me away that people think someone who has never commanded a double team is better and more important than the guy who does it all the time.

  17. Buccaneer Bonzai Says:

    People have been saying they want Evans to retire a Buc…this is part of that process.

    I value both…including the ‘future’ condition forces boas into the equation, so this poll is useless.

    I don’t consider this a tantrum. I consider it fair negotiation between a play and team.

  18. Duane in Sanford Says:

    Evans has missed 9 games in 9 seasons. Godwin has missed at least 2 of ever season he has played. Godwin has already sustained a career threatening injury, rarely sees the other teams best pass defender when Evans is playing, and only a couple of years removed from ME13. You gotta be nuts if you think Godwin would ever be a better option than Evans past, present, or future.

  19. Pickgrin Says:

    BOTH. You take care of both. And the Bucs will….

  20. Rod Munch Says:

    Mike Evans is a superstar top tier WR, on a different level than Godwin. If you don’t know that, you’re literally an idiot.

    Godwin is a great franchise level player, really really good – but he’s at the Mark Carrier level in terms of the history of the franchise (BTW, if you’re a moron who doesn’t know the team history, that is not a knock), but Evans is an all-time great WR. Those are two different level players.

  21. J Q Says:

    Godwin hasn’t done a thing in 2 years. What are you all even thinking?!? The Bucs and this site are ruining the season before it even starts

  22. Daniel Says:

    Paying 30+ year old WRs rarely ends well.

    The answer here is Godwin and it’s not close