The Sad Numbers For Baker Mayfield (And A Glimmer Of Light In The Near Future)
November 18th, 2026
Struggles nearing an end?
A week or so ago, Joe was talking with the Sage of Tampa Bay sports, Ira Kaufman, discussing what may be a turning point in the history of the Bucs: last year’s bye.
The Bucs haven’t been the same since. And neither has Bucs quarterback Baker Mayfield.
Since that bye last October, the Bucs are 5-13.
“I’d like to know what happened during the bye,” Ira told Joe, suspecting something took place behind the walls of One Buc Place that has yet to publicly surface.
It sort of reminds Joe of the time the Bucs left Tampa 4-2 after a win over the slimy Saints in 2011. They flew to London for an international game and didn’t win another game that year.
(Joe has heard all sorts of stories, some dripping with salacious innuendo. But to date, Joe has never confirmed any of the cloudy stories other than Aqib Talib and Raheem Morris had a major blowup in the team’s London hotel lobby after curfew.)
Joe has zero idea if anything nefarious took place at One Buc Palace last year, or at the team hotel in New Orleans (where the Bucs went to 6-2 just before the bye). But it is very odd that the Bucs have been a completely different team since.
More importantly, Mayfield has been a complete polar opposite quarterback.
Mayfield was a legitimate MVP candidate before last year’s bye. Since, he has hit rock bottom. Joe has already seen Bucs fans suggest Mayfield’s injured foot is just a well-crafted ruse to cover for a benching; he’s been that bad.
(No, Joe doesn’t believe this.)
Joe is shocked by how far Mayfield has fallen. It almost makes Joe wonder if he is over the hill. You don’t often see quarterbacks in their early 30s fall off the map like this unless there is something seriously wrong.
When your composite advanced statistical numbers put you at No. 32, there simply is no way of spinning that or placing blame on some other area of the team or even coaching, though Joe does believe Mike Tanier’s philosophy that one should never, ever underestimate how bad coaching can drag down a player or team.
Joe hopes Mayfield is simply a victim of a terrible offensive coordinator. Because that would mean Mayfield’s struggles are just temporary.
Joe was digging and digging and digging last night to try to find a bright spot for Mayfield that may just give Bucs fans hope for the second half of the year. Tampa Bay has one of the easiest strength-of-schedules after the Lions game on Sunday.
Mayfield when he plays a weak defense (ranked No. 17-24) he has the second-highest EPA per play of all quarterbacks, per data from the Twitter feed of @sfdata9ers.
So, even though it appears Mayfield may not be available Sunday in Detroit, afterwards, Mayfield will see a lot of lesser defenses. Then we should see if his fortunes finally turn around.

QB EPA/Play per Quarter pic.twitter.com/VzlhkdqZzU
— SFdata9ers🏈📊 (@sfdata9ers) November 17, 2026








November 18th, 2026 at 4:08 am
Part of the reason Coen left for Jacksonville he had a real QB to work with. Coen got the best out of Baker like he is with Trevor. Baker is what his record says he is, a below. 500 QB. He’s always had moments of brilliance followed by folly. As he ages it’ll only get worse. Baker’s best attribute was convincing the Glazers he was worth that ridiculous contract. Two more years of this.
November 18th, 2026 at 4:44 am
Hodad … ‘Baker’s best attribute was convincing the Glazers he was worth that ridiculous contract. Two more years of this.’
No way Hodad. I’ve already had enough of Baker Mayfield to last a lifetime. He’s performing here very similarly to how he performed in Carolina. They were smart, cut their losses early and moved on. Bucs need to do the same.
I think this Bucs’ team could win the division with Jalon Daniels as the starting QB for the remaining 8 games IF (1) the defense continues to excel; (2) our Special Teams continue to excel; and (3) our offense focuses primarily on its Running Game, with Daniels being one of the runners. We’d undoubedly need a modicum of a Passing Game to keep defenses honest, but I think Daniels is capable of that.
November 18th, 2026 at 5:05 am
Or maybe Coen was good it elevated mayfield to a temporary high that he’s not likely to see again.
Also, the the team was playing early on in ‘25 was pulling games out at the very end with hero ball. It wasn’t sustainable.
I think people need to realize that Coen got more out of the offense and mayfield than what was really there and it’s more than likely mayfield’s ceiling is below that.
The good news is that the right coach can get him to be passable as a starter again. But the “right” coach isn’t another offensive coordinator that Todd Bowles gets to pick….its an offensive mind that replaces Todd Bowles. If the glazers want to get something out of that investment then they better get that thru their skulls. It shouldn’t matter what happens the rest of the year.
November 18th, 2026 at 6:04 am
Baker the Fake. Stealing money from the organization. Makes you wonder if we would be tanking if we didn’t sign this low character village drunk for three more years. Tua 2.0
November 18th, 2026 at 6:22 am
Why is it so difficult for some people to accept that Baker isn’t a good QB? Its all his fault and he’s played like this before he came to Tampa. The way hes playing now is why the Browns and Panthers said goodbye. Nothing happened, his minimal skills deteriorated. He won’t get better, this is who he is.
A below average QB got worse with age and some people are surprised. The 2 weeks before the bye Baker wasn’t playing well.
Vs the Lions he went: 28 of 50 (56.0%), 228 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, 4 sacks (18 yards lost), 66.1 passer rating with a fumble.
Vs the Saints he went: 15 of 24 (62.5%), 152 yards, 0 TD, 0 INT, 3 sacks (28 yards lost), 80.6 passer rating with a fumble lost.
He wasn’t lighting it up before that bye week. He was just mediocre which is ceiling now.
November 18th, 2026 at 6:23 am
if baker is #2 in the league against weak defenses that says it isnt all his fault. he doesnt play in a bubble by himself. there are a lot of other players and coaches (a lot of coaches) that baker depends on getting things right so he can be successful.
baker isnt doing his part, thats for sure. he hasnt been able to put the team on his back with last drive heroics as mentioned.
the o-line is getting beat and cant handle a strong pass rush, they have taken at least a step back if not more than a step back. their penalties and pressure rate prove that out.
nothing baker can do about the o-line breakdown except for try to flee, or absorb the punishment, and he hasnt done a good job managing either by throwing picks or getting sacked.
November 18th, 2026 at 6:38 am
I think we have mediocre fans who think that Mayfields’s TDs and Passing yards his first three years here was a fluke. I don’t know what’s truly wrong with Baker, but it ain’t a lack of talent!
November 18th, 2026 at 6:41 am
question:
like why is baker doing what baker is doing…
while lamar is out and having surgery and recovering…
supposedly the same injury…
in fact, baker’s was probably worse right…?…with all the blood and bone thru the skin action, that had been mentioned a bit…
so what is baker doing…?
trying to prove he can have the worst season for a quarterback in the history of the nfl after getting the largest raise…
like really….what exactly is going on here…
he has no thumb…he has no foot…he has no stats…
like what exactly is going on with my qb….one thomas thumb
November 18th, 2026 at 7:01 am
Two quarterbacks have played this year. Give us,a composite of the,QB position. Also the wins,as,a QB stat changes on whether you already like the guy or not. The whole team wins,and loses Together. As far as running the ball goes we have not seen this,since 1952 or todays service academies. Army should have made the playoffs,recently just running the ball. The issue on the passing game is a loss of your top receiver, no meaningful work in preseason, Baker getting injured, a comically under prepared rookie and the monsoon game. Although n the pick six,was,bad,Baker also had,a bright bomb. Baker has not forgotten how to throw,as,we,saw in that bomb. He will turn it around.
November 18th, 2026 at 7:02 am
I think Lamar is,a wimp who is never,available,Adam. Toughness counts.
November 18th, 2026 at 7:11 am
Since last year, Mayfield has had the following circumstances; 1) receivers who routinely drop passes that hit them in the hands. 2) An O line that has forgotten how to pass block.3) Yet another new OC- Zak Robinson. 4) Finally many of the games last year were given away by a defense that would not hold a lead late in the game. Mayfield brought the team back from a huge deficit provided by the defense vs the Bears. At the end of the game after Mayfield led the team back to a tie, the D allowed the Bears to move quickly and easily into winning field goal range. The Bears game looked like so many in the last half of 2025.
November 18th, 2026 at 7:20 am
I’m seeing Baker have the same career decline as Russell Wilson. Seahawks weren’t as good his last year or two there, nobody wanted to say it was Russel. Denver was even worse, Giants, worse yet
November 18th, 2026 at 7:21 am
Dropping Facts:
Baker has 3 touchdowns for the season.
He is paid 55 million a year
He will have been paid 10,784, 313.70 for each touchdown pass he has thrown through week 10 (bye week).
The irony: That is almost exactly the amount of money his father stole from him.
“Baker the Faker” limped around like a little girl each time he threw a pic in the last game…then jumps around like a college cheerleader when he scored on that 2 point conversion.
A typical Austin SNOWFLAKE
November 18th, 2026 at 7:29 am
Jim Everett for the Rams had a similar falloff in the 90s. At one point he was very, very good. Then he just couldn’t play anymore. It was weird.
It might be similar to what’s happening here. I still believe in the injury scenario. Somewhere right before the bye, Mayfield got hurt and that has affected him ever since. I’m starting to think it could have been a concussion that is still bothering him. We may never know.
November 18th, 2026 at 7:36 am
I have a lot of opinions on this matter. Most are not unique and one is truly speculative conjecture.
First, when looking at that chart Mike sure seems to have been the smartest person at OBP.
Second, are these type of statistical metrics unavailable to Licht and Glazers when they are making contract decisions? Does anyone notice any correlation between the top paid QBs and that graphic, exception Mayfield.
Finally, pure theory to..
With baby number 2 enroute, [No, this site isn’t going to be the source of wild rumors of an NFL quarterback committing felonies, sorry. — Joe], but I suspect Icarus flew too close to the sun and is now crashing back to earth.
November 18th, 2026 at 7:58 am
“Warren Brooks Lynch Says:
July 3rd, 2026 at 1:30 pm
Let Baker play for the $40M he’s going to make this year. See how he does, if the law of averages bites him in the a** like it did last season we’ll have to move forward. Now, Bazelak, Daniels, not Browning are locks to be on the roster next year. I personally feel the start of the Mayfield succession plan was getting Daniels in here and gettin him acclimated with the pro level of play as well as the talent we have on hand for a year.
FFWD to pre-combine & Draft ‘27 if Baker turns back into a pumpkin in ‘26 playing like he has for the majority of his career whether it be inconsistency or the shaky ball security or a good mix of both. You eat the charge and go cheaper, holding onto Daniels and investing in a Maiava, Mensah(Hurricane-Buc pipeline revisited) or Sayin, and a few others Í need to see this college season before Í say “yea, he’d work for us”. Even this draft, I wanted us to sign Jack Strand-that’s my archetype, big, stronger and smart. Finding a QB with more touch than Baker won’t be hard. More athleticism, won’t be hard. Get me 2-3 QBs with higher ceiling than a 31 and at the time will be 32 yo Baker Mayfield. All this 3-4 yrs for him like longevity at QB is a given, when in reality it’s reserved for the QBs who’re either really established-good starters for years or career backups. No in between.”
-Warren Brooks Lynchstradamus
November 18th, 2026 at 8:00 am
Mayfield sure was P.O.’d in front of the media before he got paid.
“I’m the Franchise QB, they said I was, Pay me like I am, blah, blah, blah”
Now that he’s been paid, his media takes are basically, “It Sucks”.
Seems he accomplished what his goals were – take care of his family.
He hasn’t declined physically – he still has arm strength and can still scramble.
There are open receivers on some plays. Receivers have dropped passes, OLine pass blocking issues, Silly penalties, And there are too many turnovers and sacks by the QB – him and Daniels.
Mayfield adjusting to Robinson and Robinson adjusting to Mayfield are factors.
Mayfield is an 8 or 9 year veteran – he needs to pull his head out of wherever it is and FOCUS on Football.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:26 am
Cousins is top ten this year. It
November 18th, 2026 at 8:29 am
Joe says:
Joe hopes that is just the case here, that Mayfield is simply a victim of a terrible offensive coordinator….
—————————————————————————————-
Two Offensive coordinators in a row has been the victim of a terrible Baker. Let’s see how terrible that OC is this weekend with a different QB. Even when he played earlier this season, JD brought more life to the offense. This Change, hopefully permanent, comes at the right time because the defense will not keep playing at this level if they start feeling futility on the other side of the ball.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:29 am
Clearly cousins was Zach’s problem last year and Baker is his problem this year. Just trade Baker and watch him flourish on a team with owners that.hsve a clue.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:34 am
But but St Pete Matty and the rest of the Baker fan boys, all told us the Bucs should “PAY HIM”.
Those clowns are clueless.
There was absolutely ZERO upside to paying Baker this year.
Had Baker balled out, the Bucs still had all the leverage. But the downside of paying him was obvious and now our reality.
Paying Baker, and letting Coen walk were two of the biggest gaffs in the history of a franchise with many stupid decisions.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:39 am
Hodad; so Coen had a QB throw 41 tds, over 4500yds, a 70% completion percentage and a QB rating of 106.8, and said, man I got to get out of here, this QB is dragging me down!?? Stop it. BAKER had the second most TDs in the league for not 3 weeks…not 3 months…but for 3 YEARS!! HE is still here, but others are not…there lays your answer
November 18th, 2026 at 8:42 am
Jose, you may want to walk back your previous criticisms of Brock Purdy. It should be clear to you now that he is a darn good QB. It was clear to most of us a couple of years ago.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:49 am
Some people just refuse to face reality. Baker is a con artist and always has been.
He’s 30-30 as the Bucs QB including playoffs. But he got paid as if he has a .800 winning percentage as is an MVP. He’s neither of those. And never will be.
Blaming the OC’s every year is simply running coverage for a fraud and a liar.
That contract will go down as one of the worst decisions in Bucs history.
Still think JL is a genius? Remember that when your UDFA QB is on the field Sunday. 3-7 guaranteed.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:53 am
Mayfield is an embarrassment. I keep thinking about his diatribe about how he felt disrespected by the Bucs. Then proceeds to become the worst QB in the league. He should be benched INDEFINITELY. Start Daniel’s for the rest of this miserable failure of a season.
November 18th, 2026 at 8:57 am
@Jack Burton Mercer Says, good comparison.
I’ll take it a step further for Joe. Have Ira interview Baker on the podcast after the season, ask about what’s gone on since the 2025 bye week and Ira can pull a Jim Rome and call him Faker _ayfield to light a fire under his ass.
November 18th, 2026 at 9:01 am
Bucsarg. He’s already done that 4 times lol 😆 😂 . Baker played in the worse division in the NFL and he still haven’t done nothing. He has a top 5 defense and running game and still haven’t done anything. Oh I get it he was hurt that’s the favorite excuse everyone gives him when he plays bad!!
November 18th, 2026 at 10:11 am
Daniels is nowhere near accurate enough to be an NFL QB. Our Wide Receivers are not doing their jobs and getting open. Only Godwin has good separation stats and he doesn’t stay open for very long. Play Baker and run the football until Egbuka’s toe is 100% healthy. Run it. Constantly.
Whenever you need a first down, run counter left. Don’t listen to DR. Daniels means we will almost never pass the football. With Baker in there at least the threat remains.
November 18th, 2026 at 10:34 am
Beej – agreed on the Wilson comparison. So many similarities in their games when they are on and off.
Baker turns 32 soon. When those legs go, if they haven’t already, it’s lights out.
Need to find a qb that can consistently win from the pocket by figuring it out pre snap and with his eyes post.
—————————————————————————————————-
Also – I never heard any rumors about any Bucs felonies last year.
November 18th, 2026 at 10:39 am
“We’d undoubedly need a modicum of a Passing Game to keep defenses honest, but I think Daniels is capable of that.”
Daniels’ arm had no zip. Pittsburgh CBs were able to defend the out routes easily with either PBU or INTs.
November 18th, 2026 at 11:53 am
is he bleaker tryfield or tom thumb…you decide…
oh wait, he has a new foot injury…
should we call our hobbled hero, legs malone or johnny wobbles
November 18th, 2026 at 12:08 pm
DR
I 1000% agree
Great Post!!!!
GO BUCS!!!!
November 18th, 2026 at 12:32 pm
Bucs fans suggest Mayfield’s injured foot is just a well-crafted ruse to cover for a benching
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~B.S.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I remember seeing the play that he hurt it on.
November 18th, 2026 at 12:44 pm
@Joe
Then why do you continue to beg the question (for over a year) of what happened to our twitchy lil QB during last year’s bye to subdue him? And according to FL Statue 893.13, “use” is not a felony.
That lil waste of a QB was not worth the $450, me representing, or the horrible Monday at work hangover following the Bears game. He never once looked off a safety or made magic. He is off target, slow in his reads, and now seems scared to run out of the pocket. I had a birds eye view and he lost yet another game with his lame pick 6. Tipped balls and all. Do you truly think that lil raging man was getting all that bravado/moxy/will to play hurt from smelling salts? He is not top tier if he plays down to his OC talent. Brady had Lefty and overcame a porous OL. Instead of glad handing at lightning games, maybe its time this guy put some time into his craft, went over game plans and made adjustments, do some work with rookie WRs…nope, he just does as he does
November 18th, 2026 at 12:48 pm
A bit surprised by some veterans here quick to bail on baker. Like most qbs, each has strengths and weaknesses. Baker has proven to be top third qb. He needs a good scheme and weapons. Two plays against Chicago were made that few could’ve made.that scramble out of trouble when he hit gainwell down the sideline, and that 55 yard drop in the bucket to tez. Bakes lower body strength has prevented many a sack. A great oc emphasizes a qb strength, while scheming open easy to hit targets. A fresh oc brings instant production, confidence. Baker goes to mcvay and instantly reminds the league of his talent. Patience. It may not happen this season, but licht will lock up a top tier oc for next year .this defense is too good not to.
November 18th, 2026 at 1:31 pm
in the bucs glory days they had alstott and dunn. they should have bucky spelled by tuck, he would be the bruiser. then jalon daniels as basically the third rb. rpo every third down
November 18th, 2026 at 1:36 pm
mayfield is horrible against good defenses, the cincinati game was the real baker we would have this year, he has not improved. i can’t believe he lost to deshawn watson his nemesis, then he falls flat on his face trying to tackle the guy who ran back the pick six, baker is just sad