The Numbers Lean Playoffs

November 17th, 2026

Battling for NFC South.

It seems Bucs fans are split in two groups these days.

On the one hand (and Joe has experienced this group firsthand), any mention of the Bucs and the playoffs and melts a group of fans down. How DARE you mention “playoffs?” The Bucs are 3-6 and about to go to 3-7. You should be slapped for uttering such nonsense.

Then there is the second group. Damn right the Bucs are in a playoff hunt. Anyone who disagrees isn’t paying attention to the NFC South standings. The season is not over! Go Bucs!

Seth Walder of BSPN, a man who never met a number he didn’t like, ran the numbers and believes, yes, the Bucs are likely making the playoffs.

Tier 4: We’re leaning yes

Tampa Bay Buccaneers (3-6)
Chances to make the playoffs:
62.6%
Chances to win the NFC South: 62.3%
Chances to make the Super Bowl: 5.5%

The FPI believes the Bucs are the best team in the NFC South by a wide margin. That’s a low bar to clear, but finishing atop the division is all that matters for Tampa Bay to reach the playoffs — as it’s the only way it will get there. Quarterback Baker Mayfield missed three games (and didn’t complete a pass in a bizarre win Nov. 1 over the Falcons in a monsoon), but he has played poorly when on the field. Mayfield entered Week 10 ahead of only Justin Herbert in QBR. And now Mayfield’s status is in doubt for Week 11 due to an injury suffered last week. Still, thanks to Todd Bowles’ defense — and a reasonable belief that the passing offense will be better going forward — the Bucs are the NFC South favorites.

Mayfield is in a vortex. He’s having his worst season since joining the Bucs. By a mile. Statistically, Mayfield is the worst quarterback in the NFL right now.

Of course, he’s getting no help from his failing offensive coordinator Zac Robinson, who is going to single-handedly get this coaching staff fired in two months — unless by some miracle the Bucs finish with a 9-8 record.

And now, Mayfield is hurt again. It’s just been an awful full calendar year for him.

Old-timers still preach running the ball and defense in the final two months of the season. That the Bucs do and do very well. And, defense and a running game also travel in cold weather.

The Bucs have shown they can win by taking the ball out of Mayfield’s hands. Can that get them to a division crown and a home playoff game?

43 Responses to “The Numbers Lean Playoffs”

  1. Mark BucsFan Says:

    If baker can simply bounce back to average play, we could be a very dangerous team in January. Defense and run games win championships

  2. Bucnjim Says:

    Have to beat the Lions to start thinking about winning the division. I do believe the Bucs are the best team in the NFC South, but I know this drives some fans crazy. Being the best of the worst isn’t saying much. Being a fan since the darkest of times, I’d like to make the playoffs no matter what people think of this division.

  3. JustOneGame Says:

    Again, the season is not over but no team from the NFCS should occupy a playoff spot let alone a playoff game. Now, if one of the teams run the table and end up with a winning record, well that would be a different story

  4. Bucscoott Says:

    Great we get Bowels one more year .

  5. Optimistic Says:

    The worst of all situations if the Bucs win the NFCS. Bowles, Licht and Baker hang around 1 more year and the Bucs don’t get a high draft choice. Woe is the Bucs fan.

  6. Fishhawkbuc Says:

    Baker the Faker is stealing money. He sure doesn’t wear the boot at the local pubs. Tua 2.0

  7. Defense Rules Says:

    Optimistic … ‘The worst of all situations if the Bucs win the NFCS. Bowles, Licht and Baker hang around 1 more year and the Bucs don’t get a high draft choice. Woe is the Bucs fan.’

    Not a very optimistic analysis Optimistic. But unfortunately, it could well come to pass. The only REAL saving grace would be if we won the Super Bowl. Then it’d be worth the price, but I don’t think many would put money on that happening.

    I watch the Bucs always with the HOPE that they’ll win, regardless of how badly their season is going. Still, like probably everyone else, would love to see us draft a true franchise QB who could lead this team for many years. And that typically requires having a high Rnd 1 draft pick. Not always, but typically (Mahomes wasn’t drafted until #10 in Rnd 1 … Mitch Trubisky was drafted well before Patrick (in Rnd 1 #2) and so was Leonard Fournette (Rnd 1 #4).

  8. Anyhony Says:

    You don’t have to outrun the Bear, just the Panther, Saint and Falcon!!!

  9. Alanbucsfan Says:

    The Bucs have a good team with the exception of the QB position, for whatever reason.
    They could sign Arians to coach, or they could trade for Mac Jones or Joe Flacco…
    If they don’t make any moves, fans are stuck with rooting for Mayfield to figure himself out or hoping Daniels can play relatively mistake-free.
    A shame to waste this good Defense and Great FG kicker on incompetent QB play.

  10. Lightningvinny1 Says:

    Riddle me this,,, in Bakers worst season as a QB does making the playoffs and winning home playoff games against Seattle and Giants (a 3,4 matchup ) automatically vault it to Bakers best season ever ? He seems to be blamed for the playoff losses so I assume same would apply for the playoff wins !
    And for those NFC South shouldn’t get a playoff spot people ,, the NFC East may end up pound for pound the worst division in the NFL, Say these match ups Carolina/Gianrs, Bucs/Boys, Falcons/Skins, Saints/Eagles ,,, Seems pretty close

  11. yucboi Says:

    I dont want the Bucs to be the first team in NFL history to win a division and make the playoffs with a 6-11 record

  12. BucaneroJim Says:

    I will say again, American football is a multi- billion dollar industry and this is the best we get? The NFL is the pinnacle and this is the best we get? Incredible!

  13. Marky mark Says:

    Fishhawkbuc if your were as good as managing your money as you are at managing the, Glasers money you could buy the Bucs,and,ManU too.

  14. Lt. Dan Says:

    Playoffs? Pa-pa-pa-pa playoffs? Put me in the slap Joe crowd. IF – the Bucs make the playoffs…what are they going to do? My guess is shat the bed. Making the playoffs only puts the Bucs further away from a decent draft pick.

  15. Marky mark Says:

    Are you a fan if you want your team to lise on.purpise just to get rid of people you personally hate?

  16. Marky mark Says:

    Some people just never get criticized. Herbert is worse than Baker and on a winless v team yet somehow still gets c touted for potential. Same with Burrows. Missed most of last season and has not made the playoffs in years but somehow he is a god. Joe us having a good season but he is no different then Baker being up and down.

  17. Gipper Says:

    Pretty sick of all the creepy losers on these pages who badmouth Mayfield at every turn. Baker Mayfield who had the second highest NFL TD pass totals for his three full years in Tampa ended 1995. The crew of losers led by marching band girl Rod Munch, need to be medicated for their obsessive behavior.

  18. Marine Buc Says:

    @ Joe

    LOL!!!!!

    AWWWW – it’s been so rough on poor Baker – the dude who just stole $165M Glazor dork dollars…

    I hope Baker is sleeping OK – whatever will the poor guy do after he is fired next season?

    I guess he will have to sell used cars or work for UPS.

    Poor little guy – I feel so bad for him.

    HAHA x 1000…

  19. Marine Buc Says:

    * Glazer

  20. MonsVenusVIP Says:

    @Defense: spot on. I root for the Bucs because I want to see them win games despite all of their miscues. I’m smart enough to know with the current cast of characters in place, the mediocrity will continue to infect the building because it’s been allowed to fester. They win the division or make a run at it, it costs a higher draft pick, Bowles and Co. will be retained, and we just get more of the same next year. The only coach I’d like to see stick around is Danny Smith. He essentially replaced Tom Moore as the wiseman in the building.

  21. First Last Says:

    If I was the coach and knew I was getting fired I would do the following:

    1) Bench Faker FumbleField until the playoffs. Statistically, he is the best QB in the playoffs lol
    2) Tell him he sucks every day and that he needs to back-up Jalon Daniels
    3) Let Jalon ride us into the playoffs because it is basically a lock if we win the NFC South
    4) First playoff game tell Baker he better go out and win us a game or I’m cutting him next year
    5) Angry Mayfield that is healthy is best mayfield
    6) ???
    7) win superbowl

  22. Been there since the beginning Says:

    Ok ya’ll, If Daniels is helped out by passes being caught and the Oline working for their pay and the Defense shows up ready, maybe with a couple picks can help us win. Ain’t no quarterback running around all day going to truly be as effective as standing in the pocket so, I’m hoping for the best. With that said, Let’s Go 1st round top 10 pick Quarterback in April!!!! Baker has taken the Big Dump on us so take the guaranteed money and get the F#ck out biatch. He might take the lead in one column in his life, being hurt.

  23. DungyDance Says:

    Not that Zac is up to the task, but what we need to complement the running plays are some 4-yd and very fast “timing” passes. Like, in 1-1.5 seconds after the snap, the throw is going to a particular place on the field, and it is the receiver’s job to be at that spot by the time 1 second arrives. If the receiver gets immediately blocked or is doubled, throw it away. All of our passing downs take waaaaaaayyyy too long to develop, and Baker is staring down his targets. Hurry it the F up, and you don’t need to look at the guy cuz you know exactly where the pass will go if you have more plays like this.

  24. HeavyE Says:

    I’m not going to feel sorry for a guy, that’s making 165mil, and playing like $hit!!! & all of a sudden, he is hurt again, after throwing bad passes, or getting picked off!

  25. itzok Says:

    there are two types of bucs fans delusional ones and those who know Bowles is our head Coach

    They aren’t making the payoffs and I’m not banging Sydney Sweeney in the next 12 months

  26. can-we-get-rid-of-Licht-for-godsake? Says:

    hmm .. maybe – over at NFL.com they have the Panthers at 50% and Bucs 36% – so let’s see – let’s presume the Bucs are 3-7 and the Panthers 5-5 before MNF – the Panthers are favored to beat BAL – the MNF game is the key to everything – if the Bucs lose it will be 6-5 CAR 3-8 TB – then Bucs must go 5-1 and Panthers 2-4 to both end 8-9 .. CAR could lose to PIT SEA CIN MIN but if they can beat ATL NO at home they will have a 5-1 div record – let’s say the Bucs lose to only LAR they would also have a 5-1 div record – in common games CAR beat DET while Bucs lost so we’d lose the 3rd tie-breaker – so essentially the Bucs have to sweep if they lose on MNF to CAR – and hope CAR goes 2-4 – so the MNF game is the first playoff game for the BUcs – win they are in – lose and they are out

  27. ProffeserVonBrainStorm Says:

    Chances to make the Super Bowl: 0.0%

    Unless Baker uses some of his stolen riches to buy tickets for the entire team.

    This is so ridiculous to even ponder. A .333 winning percentage is being celebrated.

    Todd has revolutionized the NFL. Forward passes are a thing of the past.

    There’s no need to ever draft a QB again. UDFA QB’s are the wave of the future!

    🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  28. TheUKBuccaneer Says:

    If you want the Bucs to tank and get a high draft pick, I’m gonna question whether you’ve paid any attention to an NFL draft, ever.

  29. McBay Says:

    In many ways this team is more exciting than the 2020 Bucs. It doesn’t get any better than that Bears game.

  30. Rob Says:

    If the Bucs go on a heater and the offense starts to compliment how good the D is then who wouldnt want to see what can happen. Teams have won the Super Bowl (Giants, Packers, Rams) when they overcame serious challenges during the regular season and carried momentum into the playoffs. There’s a big difference between riding into the playoffs on fire at 10-7 and limping in at 7-10 or 8-9.

  31. Permanently Moderated Says:

    I’ve never rooted against the Bucs and never will. However, it’s hard to get too far out there when you’ve been a fan since the day the franchise was announced. So many times in the past the Bucs have let us down. So many bad seasons. I’m now more realistic than optimistic. Please forgive me.

  32. Marky mark Says:

    If we are talking stolen riches than Action Jackson is the biggest thief. Out again on the,same injury That Baker got. Lamar is,a thief and a wimp who cant play with pain like,Baker can.

  33. can-we-get-rid-of-Licht-for-godsake? Says:

    Week 14 should be interesting :
    Falcons will be 3-10 eliminated after losses to MIN DET CLE
    Saints will be 3-9 and facing elimination by the Panthers in Charlotte
    Panthers face a must-win div game and would need only a win Week 18 for title
    Bucs face a must-win game at BAL to keep hopes alive for playoffs

  34. Marky mark Says:

    Here’s the situation:
    – Injured his foot in the November 8 loss to Chicago.
    – Has been in and out of a walking boot during the bye week.
    – Injury is not considered long-term.
    – His availability for Sunday’s game against Detroit is uncertain.
    – Tampa Bay signed veteran QB Cooper Rush to its practice squad Monday as insurance. Bay News 9
    Important: The first regular practice of the week is Wednesday, November 18. We should get a much better indication then.

  35. adam from ny Says:

    basically all the teams the bucs lost to, just keep getting better and better…

    i wonder what their cumulative record is now…it was like 29-15 at one point a few weeks back…it had to only get better…

    maybe a stat man like DEFENSE can pull it up or put it together…?

    we’ve been crushed by the stellar afc north and the nfc north this year…and all of them seem headed to the playoffs

  36. adam from ny Says:

    i just figured it out…

    the combined record of the teams we lost to is 39-17

    how crazy is that

  37. GMC hater Says:

    Making the playoffs in this division means NOTHING!!! This season is a failure unless by some miracle Bucs get a playoff win!

  38. Lightningvinny1 Says:

    The game VS Carolina is super important , it’s a make or break game as Carolina still has Cinci, Minn, Steelers and Seattle left ,, After Detroit the Bucs will have played the hard part of their schedule ,, it can happen folks

  39. adam from ny Says:

    and……

    if we lose to detroit and baltimore…

    both away games…

    we will have been “cold swept”….clean sweepage…by the nfc north and the afc north…

    time to ball out in detroit rock city

  40. 40 year Bucs fan Says:

    Yeah right lol. They shouldn’t have been trying to build around baker for so long and been trying to draft a franchise qb which baker is clearly not.

  41. fishhawkbuc Says:

    @markymark ~ get off moms couch and get to work. You gotta be Baker’s drinking buddy up at the Anchor Bar. He sure can hobble into that place WITHOUT a boot. Does he pay your tab, or better yet – does he push your stool in?

  42. fishhawkbuc Says:

    Baker has 3 touchdowns for the season.
    He is paid 55 million a year
    He will have been paid 10,784, 313.70 for each touchdown pass he has thrown through week 10 (bye week).
    The irony: That is almost exactly the amount of money his father stole from him.
    The Hope: Baker the Faker may mentally call it even (him stealing from the Bucs) and start to play much better.
    “Baker the Faker” limped around like a little girl each time he threw a pic in the last game…then jumps around like a college cheerleader when he scored on that 2 point conversion.
    A typical Austin SNOWFLAKE

  43. Buccaneer Bonzai Says:

    Seth Walder is an idiot. Nothing so far suggests playoffs.

    That doesn’t mean it cannot happen, but it is not trending that way…so far.

 

Leave a Reply