Holding Penalties Adding Up
November 17th, 2026
Way too many holding calls.
The Bucs’ passing game is trash and Baker Mayfield is having his worst season as a Bucs quarterback, by far.
Mayfield’s numbers are so bad, they are bench-worthy. He’s broken. And Joe doesn’t know if failed Bucs offensive coordinator Zac Robinson can fix him. The playoffs may hinge on Robinson’s ability to do so — or doom the team with Robinson’s inability.
Mayfield is not getting help from his teammates and Mayfield cannot control this unless he wants to punch someone.
The Bucs are one of the worst teams when it comes to offensive holding.
Joe isn’t one of those guys who always blames a ref for a flag. Sometimes, Joe swears players are being coached up to do illegal things with the hope zebras don’t see it.
When is the last time you watched a game, for example, when you didn’t see a corner grab a receiver’s jersey? Are players really that stupid not to know grabbing a jersey is an automatic flag?
No, Joe thinks these guys are being coached up to, um, ignore certain rules. Joe doesn’t know if the Bucs are being taught to hold, but Joe is guessing players are taught a blocking technique where getting caught for holding is more likely than not.
Joe is a big Kevin Carberry fan. The Bucs’ offensive line nearly got the Bucs’ offensive line to the playoffs last year with so many injuries. That’s some serious coaching.
Anyway, Joe guesses either failed offensive coordinator Zac Robinson or Carberry himself are using either a new tactic or a new technique that puts players in the uncomfortable position to get holding calls.
Per the following graphic from Twitter stathead @sfdata9ers, the Bucs are the fourth-worst team for offensive holding calls through the NFL’s first nine weeks.
Holding calls are drive killers. The Bucs need to get this cleaned up. Pronto.
The Bucs’ passing attack is garbage. No need to make it worse by continuing to get whistled for holding penalties.









November 17th, 2026 at 4:49 am
Just another thing that ultimately falls on bowles’ shoulders (everything does, he’s the head ball coach). And just like most other issues with this team, he either doesn’t have the will, or more likely the ability, to get it fixed. You think if the Pats were 4th worst in the league at ANYTHING while BB was running the show he would let it continue?
#FIREbowles
November 17th, 2026 at 5:35 am
Another example of the subtle other things that this coaching staff excels at. Maybe the Bucs are the 4th most penalized team for holding, but that means they’re probably getting away with way more than is called, which is an advantage. Another example of Todd’s genius.
November 17th, 2026 at 5:43 am
Joe … ‘Holding calls are drive killers.’
You’re right Joe, but I think it’s mostly because the NFL rules are biased. Offensive holding gets a 10-yard penalty; defensive holding gets a 5-yard penalty. Why? Holding is holding.
Good old AI provided a somewhat-logical rationale: ‘The rules treat the two fouls differently based on their impact and intent:
• Offensive holding (10 yards + replay down): Offensive linemen have a huge physical advantage in pass protection and run blocking. If an offensive lineman illegally grabs, tackles, or restricts a defender to prevent a sack or a tackle for loss, it creates an illegal pocket or lane. The 10-yard step-back acts as a major deterrent and a “drive killer” to offset the unfair time or space the offense gained. (Historically, it used to be a 15-yard penalty before being lowered to 10 yards in 1974.)
• Defensive holding (5 yards + automatic first down): Defensive holding (such as a DB grabbing a receiver downfield) is shorter in yardage (5 yards), but it carries an automatic first down. Even though the yardage loss is small, awarding a fresh set of downs makes it equally punishing—especially on third down—because it prevents a defense from intentionally fouling to wipe out a conversion opportunity.’
Still, to me it seems like the offense ends up paying a bigger penalty. It’s really hard for most offenses to recover from a 10-yard holding penalty. Studies suggest that an ‘NFL offense recovers to convert a first down (or score a touchdown) on roughly 12% to 14% of series that feature an offensive holding penalty, compared to a normal baseline conversion rate of about 66% for a standard 1st-and-10’. That’s a pretty severe hit.
November 17th, 2026 at 6:42 am
I’m not making excuses for the crap we’ve been seeing, but the refs are out of control this year with holding calls. If look up the numbers league wide the refs are calling holding a lot more this year than in previous seasons. No matter who you are (or not) a fan of I can guarantee none of us a paying to see the referee’s throw a bunch of flags.
November 17th, 2026 at 6:42 am
Offensive linemen hold a defender when they get beat…
That’s the real issue.
November 17th, 2026 at 7:20 am
one of the worst in holding, worst in pressure rate, one of the worst in sack rate,
not a great year for this o-line. “gel” or needing to “re-gel” after not playing together much last year is no longer a valid excuse. the bad o-line stats might explain some of bakers issues, not all though.
maybe goedeke can shed some light on these stats vs his declarations of greatness the other day.
November 17th, 2026 at 7:27 am
I’m not sure, but I have a feeling a lot of those holding calls were on running plays, and the Bucs are running a lot. It would be interesting to see how the calls break down, run vs pass.
November 17th, 2026 at 7:43 am
Marine Buc is right! They’ve been getting beat off the ball since the Bengals game. It looks like the same interior stunt the Defenses run most of the time. Not to mention the blitz teams are running of Goedeke’s side has almost gotten both QBs killed. Holding, false starts, you name it. Things are not right with this team’s pass blocking.
November 17th, 2026 at 8:12 am
Maybe they hold because they can’t pass block. Combine the holding penalties with the Inability to pass block and receivers who aren’t getting separation (coaching problem there) and the result is happy feet and a putrid passing game. Happy feet don’t begin until it becomes evident the pass blocker has clearly lost his rep. Pass rushers can get close but as long as the blocker stays in position and maintains control, the quarterback can wait for a play to develop. That’s the type of pressure our pass rush frequently exhibits, gradually getting closer but infrequently arriving in time. There are different types of pressure, the gradual type and the “Katy bar the door” type. When we are dropping back to pass we frequently get the latter type.
November 17th, 2026 at 8:28 am
It’s simple. They are holding because they are getting beat…
November 17th, 2026 at 8:33 am
They say that a good offensive line plays as one. As a fan, the best I can usually tell is if “we’re” winning or losing the line of scrimmage. I believe we’ve been winning the line of scrimmage- on both sides of the ball, since the 4th week of the season.
Opening day I was shocked our OLine was losing. We were just rusty. We’re still getting better. Our passing game is ugly even when we’ve got it blocked.
Surely, with the lines of scrimmage we are blessed to have this year, we oughta be able to get on a run. Right? I’m waiting!
November 17th, 2026 at 8:39 am
Also meant to add that some of our holding calls have sucked. When I played, OLineman had to clench their fists when they blocked. We changed that rule along time ago, and for a reason.
November 17th, 2026 at 8:56 am
Poor coaching leads to poor results. We have a HC that can’t beat teams with a winning record. Simple math tells you he’s the problem.
As far as the refs go, they are an extension of Vegas. Thumbs are on the scale.
They don’t even try to hide it anymore. That’s why they show you betting odds during the game. All sports are in on it these days.
It’s a soap opera for fat guys. Just enjoy it when the script has your team written in as the hero. Bowles is written in as the court jester.
November 17th, 2026 at 9:26 am
Some said it right, they are holding because they are getting beat! BAKER is under duress as soon as ball is snapped, and the O.C has no play calls for a quick timing pattern while the receivers are in motion!! This 6 yd horizontal game and WRs running to a spot and squatting down is what has stalled this offense and Baker! The guy had the second most touchdown passes in the whole league his first 3 years!! Read that again…Mayfield is still on the team, but who is NOT!? There lies your answer
November 17th, 2026 at 11:49 am
There’s some pretty mediocre teams listed at the top of that list with the least amount of holding calls.
I’m guessing those teams make other stupid mistakes. LOL
Like maybe not holding and letting your quarterback get killed.
November 17th, 2026 at 1:00 pm
That stat is for dysfunctional teams. What does that say about the Buccaneers.