CBS Ranking Shows How Far Baker Mayfield Has Fallen

November 19th, 2026

Bucs QB Baker Mayfield.

After losing to the Bears where once again Bucs quarterback Baker Mayfield and the Bucs’ passing offense didn’t pass the smell test, Joe typed that “Baker Mayfield is broken.”

Joe hopes that is the case because if something is broken, it means it can be repaired. The alternative, which Joe is beginning to fear, is much worse.

Joe has also documented that through the Bucs’ nine games played this season, Mayfield, in a composite of advanced statistics, is the league’s No. 32-ranked quarterback.

Well, Bryan DeArdo of CBS decided to rank every quarterback who has started a game in the NFL this season. Let’s just say he does not even have Mayfield ranked as high as No. 32.

In fact, DeArdo has Bucs backup quarterback Jalon Daniels ranked just ahead of Mayfield.

He threw just 14 combined passes in his two wins as Tampa Bay’s starting quarterback. He made odd history in Week 8 by becoming the first quarterback since 1974 to win a start without completing a single pass.

DeArdo has Daniels ranked No. 38, Mayfield No. 39.

Joe has no idea what has happened to Mayfield since he put the Bucs on his back to beat the 49ers last October. He’s a completely different quarterback.

Joe doesn’t know if the Bucs are hiding an injury, if failed Bucs offensive coordinator Zac Robinson has his head screwed up, or if something happened last year that Mayfield has yet to overcome.

Something happened. Unless Mayfield got beat up just before the bye last year — he played banged up against the slimy Saints in Lincoln’s Tomb just before the bye. Maybe he is still dealing with an injury that he absorbed just before that game?

The way Mayfield has sharply fallen off the map since last October, it almost makes Joe think that the 31-year old has already peaked. Maybe all the years of playing devil-may-care football and all the punishment that came with that style of play have caught up with him?

Joe can say this: If Mayfield were at, say, 70 percent on Sunday, is 70 percent of the No. 32 quarterback in the league that much of a difference from Daniels?

Heal up, Baker! Get your body right. Bucs are still in the playoff hunt.

12 Responses to “CBS Ranking Shows How Far Baker Mayfield Has Fallen”

  1. Leopold Stotch Says:

    boy oh boy, sure glad we signed him. dirty word coming up so hang in there… i HOPE he can fix it.

  2. Leopold Stotch Says:

    boy oh boy, sure glad we signed him. dirty word coming up so hang in there… i HOPE he can fix it.

  3. Hodad Says:

    This is what happened with Mayfield in Cleveland, Carolina, and now Tampa. This is who, and what Baker is, and has always been. His play has always been wildly high, and low. More lows, than highs, and as he ages, with mounting injuries it’ll only get worse. He’ll be the bridge in 27, the backup in 28, gone in 29. He was given a massive contract by clueless ownership, and a ineffective GM. Baker ain’t broken, he’s what he’s always been. We’re just seeing it more clearly the more we see Baker.

  4. Buccanstopit Says:

    After last years collapse, I wanted him to play out his contract to see how this year went. It would have been easier to kill two birds with one stone, not overpay for the QB

  5. Colin in Canada Says:

    These season stats are meaningless until the season is completed.

  6. Fishhawkbuc Says:

    DeArdo has some real reporting. The local press is fat to timid to report in a similar fashion

  7. Oneilbuc Says:

    I’ve been saying this since 2023 that the bucs was not winning nothing with Baker at quarterback. Kyle Trask out played him in training camp in 2023 but when you tell the truth they call you a Trask fan or a Baker hater when you just calling it like you see it.

  8. ChiBuc Says:

    @Hodad, well said on all points, speaking the truth

  9. ChiBuc Says:

    But, but….
    He’s injured,
    It’s the OC,
    The WRs don’t get separation,
    His OL doesn’t protect him,
    If only he had a running game,
    The defensive can’t preserve a lead,
    Todd Bowles is Baker’s problem!!

    Pfft. Baker’s problems are Baker
    “The greatest obstacles in life are often the ones we create in our own minds.” Albert King

  10. fishhawkbuc Says:

    10.7 million per TD pass this season. Baker the Faker is laughing all the way to the bank.
    Character issue always surface to the top when lifelong financial stability is obtained. ~
    🤑Stealing money, just like pops.
    🍹Always at the local bar(s). Even during rehab. AKA Village Drunk
    🩼Fakes injuries in order to avoid the forthcoming poor play on the field.

  11. fishhawkbuc Says:

    Real franchise QB’s make their receivers better players. Look at Brady/Manning/Brees/Favre/Etc. ~ they had a revolving door of WR’s and they ALWAYS dominated in the passing game.

  12. Warren Brooks Lynch Says:

    “The way Mayfield has sharply fallen off the map since last October, it almost makes Joe think that the 31-year old has already peaked. Maybe all the years of playing devil-may-care football and all the punishment that came with that style of play have caught up with him?”

    Great point Joe, and until it can be proven otherwise it’s something you’d at least have to consider. Mayfield has never been a top tier athlete, and as much as his IQ gets talked about in between games some of the decisions in-game don’t always line up with the talk.

 

Leave a Reply