Dominik picked players that are weak. Is that is fault? Eh… he’s not a doctor, but his track record for finding the walking wounded is ASTOUNDING.

The best move Dominik has made as GM was NOT signing Antonio Bryant to an extension. Literally his BEST decision as GM was a move he DIDN’T make.

I lose a bit of confidence in Freeman every week. I liked him when he was running. He was like a faster Duante Culpepper in 2010. Someone got in his head to try and be Peyton Manning and that’s not him. I don’t know why on 3rd and 1 it’s not 6’6″ Freeman behind Carl Nicks for 2 yards. I asked the same questions last year when Joseph was the G. We’re down to ONE Dominik pick that has actually lived up to expectation: Claiborne. Everyone else was drafted for one reason and is moonlighting as something else, or is hurt, or is gone.

There isn’t a rookie corner that is doing well this season so I really do not understand what you are talking about. Hakeem Nicks torched Clairborn for Dallas. The only reason they didn’t have more yardage was because they adjusted and gave him safety help over the top so he wouldn’t get beat deep plus the drop balls helped.

Talib had no help what so ever and without the pass rush he was in coverage extra. Dallas adjusted the bucs didn’t.

First Draft
1) Freeman – eh (arguably the best qb picked in that draft)
2) Winslow – gone (played 3 very good years)
3) Miller – Good backup (good backup for a 3rd not shabby)
4) Moore – Gone (agree but its a 4)
5) Fulton – Gone (agree but its a 5)
7) Biggers – dime corner (a #2, #3 cb. He is a good depth cb in the 7th)
8) Stroughter – special teams (He is a SOLID receiver and sp. teamer in the 7th)

Second
1) McCoy – one injury from bust (Solid on the field, nobody could’ve guessed injuries)
2) Price – gone (terrible luck with injuries worthy of mulligan)
2) Benn – doesnt play (very good receiver when healthy)
3) Lewis – dreadful (ya bad pick.. why not playing safety)
4) Williams – great pick (agree)
6) Bowden – gone (silly pick)
7) Grimm – doesnt play (was a good pick for a 7th)
7) Watson – solid (agree)
7) Lorig – dreadful (a good fb in the 7th.. not dreadful)

Draft 3
1) Clayborne – good (Hope so)
2) Bowers – injured (boom or bust pick for injury.. so far bust)
3) Foster – good (should be solid)
4) Stocker – dreadful (Where is he)
5) Black – we’ll see (Seems to be a baller)
6) Bradford – gone (who? )
7) Gaitor – stays on roster, doesnt play (Seems to be working up into the mix)
7) Some tight end – exactly (Didn’t make it into regular season)

……….

Taking a more realistic look into Dom’s draft picks would lead you into believing that he has had a several solid picks, some silly picks and a few bad luck picks. I’d say he’s batting a little above 500 which is pretty good for a GM.

He’s not GM Genie but there are definitely worse GM’s out there. I’d even put him in the upper ring of GMs. Every year the pundits give praise to the moves that Dom does in the offseason.

.. He’s not Mike Tennenbaum trading into the top 10 to grab Mark Sanchez and then trading for Tim Tebow

Never doubt that!

Lewis is just a pretty boy!

If anything, I’m thinking Dominik looks WORSE. Claiborne has disappeared. Freeman is throwing bonehead passes into the middle of the field (a la 2011). Legarette Blount has been invisible. And passing on a CB in the draft is starting to look like a supremely stupid move.

The only bright spot looks to be Doug Martin.

—————————————————————————————–

Do you have any evidence of this happening? Just like people falling apart from the 6x-110 you always bring up?

2.2 inches did all of us a huge favor by believing his own hype, and being stupid enough to believe that he had autonomy here on JBF. We all know that Joe can do absolutely anything and everything he wants, any time he wants. Joe’s site, Joe’s rules.–And that is how it should be. Now we can only wait for the day that Joe decides to remove what is decidedly the worst part of JBF. Namely, Little Michelle. She has shown to be unworthy of The New Schiano Order. And, more importantly, unworthy of JBF.

It isn’t the scab ref’s fault by the way. They are doing the best they can. They aren’t qualified to do the job they are being asked to do. It would be like hiring a night club bouncer to be a police officer,